Homeowners Insurance

Wildfire Non-Renewals in Colorado: What Homeowners Need to Know

RightQuote Team
Wildfire Non-Renewals in Colorado: What Homeowners Need to Know

The letter arrives in the mail with no warning. Your homeowners insurance carrier — the one you have been with for eight years, the one that covered your hail claim two summers ago without a fight — is informing you that your policy will not be renewed at the end of your current term.

The reason? Wildfire exposure.

This is happening to thousands of Colorado homeowners right now, and the pace is accelerating. If you live in the wildland-urban interface — the neighborhoods where development meets open land along the Front Range — you are in the crosshairs of one of the most significant insurance market shifts in Colorado history.

Here is what is driving it, what your options are, and what you need to do if it happens to you.

Why Carriers Are Leaving Colorado

The short answer is losses. The longer answer involves a decade of catastrophic wildfire events, reinsurance costs that have tripled, and state regulations that have historically made it difficult for carriers to price Colorado wildfire risk accurately.

The Waldo Canyon Fire in 2012 and the Black Forest Fire in 2013 were wake-up calls. The Marshall Fire in December 2021 — which burned through suburban Boulder County neighborhoods that most people would never have considered wildfire-prone — was a turning point. Over 1,000 homes destroyed in a matter of hours, in a community with manicured lawns and paved streets. The industry's models for Colorado wildfire risk were fundamentally wrong, and carriers knew it.

Since then, several major carriers have stopped writing new homeowners policies in high-risk Colorado zip codes. Others have non-renewed existing policyholders in wildfire-adjacent areas. And the carriers that are still writing policies have raised rates significantly — in some cases 40 to 60 percent over two years — while adding wildfire-specific exclusions or sublimits that many homeowners do not notice until they file a claim.

Which Areas Are Most Affected

The non-renewal pressure is concentrated in areas the industry classifies as Wildfire Risk Score 7 or higher on the FireLine or Verisk wildfire risk models. In the Colorado Springs area, that includes:

  • Black Forest — heavily wooded, high fuel load, history of significant fire activity

  • Broadmoor and Cheyenne Mountain — interface with open space and steep terrain
  • Woodmen Hills and Falcon — eastern plains interface with dry grass fuel
  • Manitou Springs — canyon terrain with limited egress

In the Denver metro, similar pressure exists in Jefferson County foothills communities, parts of Douglas County, and the Boulder County areas affected by the Marshall Fire.

If you are not sure where your property falls on the risk spectrum, we can run a wildfire risk assessment for your address as part of a coverage review.

What Happens When You Get a Non-Renewal Notice

First, do not panic — but do act quickly. Colorado law requires carriers to give you at least 45 days notice before a non-renewal takes effect. Some carriers give 60 days. Either way, you have a window, and the earlier you start shopping, the more options you will have.

Here is the sequence:

Read the notice carefully. Non-renewals are different from cancellations. A non-renewal means the carrier is choosing not to continue the policy at the end of the current term. A cancellation mid-term is a different situation with different rules. Make sure you understand which one you are dealing with.

Do not wait for your renewal date. Start shopping immediately. The admitted market — standard carriers regulated by the Colorado Division of Insurance — has contracted significantly in high-risk areas. But the surplus lines market, which includes carriers like Lloyd's of London syndicates and specialty admitted carriers, is still actively writing Colorado wildfire risk. These policies typically cost more, but they exist.

Call RightQuote. As an independent agency working with 20-plus carriers, we have access to both the admitted and surplus lines markets. We can tell you quickly what is available for your specific address, what it will cost, and what the coverage differences are between your current policy and the alternatives.

The FAIR Plan: Last Resort, Not First Choice

Colorado has a FAIR Plan — the Colorado Homeowners Insurance Risk Reduction Program — which is designed as a market of last resort for homeowners who cannot find coverage in the standard market. It provides basic fire coverage when nothing else is available.

The FAIR Plan is better than no coverage, but it is not a substitute for a comprehensive homeowners policy. It covers fire damage but typically does not include liability coverage, theft, or many of the other protections in a standard policy. If you end up on the FAIR Plan, you will likely need to purchase a separate "difference in conditions" policy to fill the gaps.

We have helped clients navigate the FAIR Plan when necessary, but our goal is always to find a better option first.

What You Can Do to Improve Your Insurability

Carriers are not just looking at your zip code — they are increasingly looking at your specific property's mitigation measures. Homes that have taken concrete steps to reduce wildfire risk are more attractive to underwriters, and in some cases can qualify for coverage that would otherwise be unavailable.

Steps that matter to underwriters:

Defensible space. Colorado law requires 30 feet of defensible space around structures in wildfire-prone areas, but many carriers want to see 100 feet. Clear dead vegetation, trim trees away from the roofline, and remove wood piles from against the house.

Class A roofing. If your roof is wood shake or an older composition shingle, replacing it with a Class A fire-rated material (metal, tile, or Class A asphalt) can meaningfully change how carriers view your property.

Ember-resistant vents. Embers entering through attic and foundation vents are a leading cause of home ignition during wildfires. Replacing standard vents with ember-resistant models is a relatively low-cost improvement that some carriers specifically ask about.

Exterior materials. Non-combustible siding, enclosed eaves, and multi-pane windows all reduce ignition risk and can factor into underwriting decisions.

We can walk you through which improvements are most likely to affect your insurability and whether the investment makes sense given your current coverage situation.

The Rate Increase Problem

Even homeowners who have not received non-renewal notices are feeling the market shift. Colorado homeowners insurance rates have increased 30 to 50 percent on average over the past three years, with wildfire-adjacent properties seeing even steeper increases.

If your renewal came in significantly higher than last year and you have not shopped it, you should. The market is not uniform — different carriers price Colorado wildfire risk very differently, and there is often a meaningful spread between the highest and lowest quotes for the same property.

This is exactly where an independent agency earns its value. We shop your risk across the full market rather than being limited to one carrier's pricing. In a volatile market like Colorado's right now, that access matters.

The Bottom Line

The Colorado homeowners insurance market is genuinely difficult right now, and wildfire risk is the primary driver. But difficult does not mean impossible. Coverage exists — it just requires knowing where to look and having relationships with the carriers that are still actively writing Colorado risk.

If you have received a non-renewal notice, if your rates have jumped significantly, or if you simply want to understand where you stand before the next renewal, call us at (719) 591-2036. We are Colorado-based, we understand this market, and we are licensed in 46 states with access to carriers that most local agents cannot reach.

ShareFacebookLinkedInX
#wildfire insurance#non-renewal#Colorado homeowners#Front Range#insurance market
🦉

Owl Quote You Right.

Ready to see what you should actually be paying? We compare coverage and pricing across our carrier network — free and unbiased.

Get My Free Quote