Many business owners use independent contractors specifically to avoid the cost and complexity of workers compensation insurance. The strategy works — when the workers are genuinely independent contractors. When they are not, the consequences can be severe.
The Independent Contractor Exception
Workers compensation requirements apply to employees, not independent contractors. If a worker is a legitimate independent contractor, you generally do not need to provide workers comp coverage for them.
But "independent contractor" is not just a label you apply to a worker. It is a legal classification with specific criteria — and state workers comp agencies, the IRS, and courts scrutinize it carefully.
How States Determine Employee vs. Contractor Status
Different states use different tests, but common factors include:
Behavioral control:
- Do you control how the work is done, not just the result?
- Do you set the worker's schedule?
- Do you provide training on how to do the work?
Financial control:
- Does the worker have a significant investment in their own tools and equipment?
- Can the worker work for other clients?
- Is the worker paid by the job or by the hour?
- Can the worker make a profit or loss on the work?
Nature of the relationship:
- Is there a written contract describing the relationship?
- Are the services a key part of your regular business?
- Is the relationship permanent or for a specific project?
A worker who is told when to show up, how to do the work, and is paid by the hour looks a lot like an employee — regardless of what the contract says.
The Misclassification Risk
If a worker you classified as an independent contractor is injured and a state agency determines they were actually an employee, you face:
- Liability for all workers comp benefits the worker would have received
- Penalties for failing to carry required workers comp coverage
- Back taxes and penalties for employment taxes you did not withhold
- Potential criminal charges in egregious cases
The injured worker's medical bills, lost wages, and disability benefits become your personal liability — without the protection of an insurance policy.
Requiring Contractors to Carry Their Own Workers Comp
One way to manage this risk is to require independent contractors to carry their own workers comp coverage and provide a certificate of insurance before starting work.
If a contractor has their own workers comp coverage:
- Their insurer covers their work-related injuries
- Your exposure is significantly reduced
- You have documentation that the contractor is operating as a legitimate independent business
This does not eliminate all risk — a contractor's workers comp policy may not cover all situations — but it substantially reduces your exposure.
The Uninsured Subcontractor Problem
If you hire subcontractors who do not have workers comp coverage, many states will hold you responsible for their injuries. This is called the "statutory employer" doctrine — you become the employer of last resort for workers comp purposes.
This is a significant risk for general contractors, construction companies, and any business that regularly uses subcontractors. Require certificates of insurance from every subcontractor before they start work.
Sole Proprietors and Partners: A Special Case
Sole proprietors and partners are typically exempt from workers comp requirements for themselves — but they can elect to be covered. If you hire a sole proprietor as a contractor, check your state's rules about whether they need to carry workers comp.
In Colorado, sole proprietors without employees are exempt from workers comp requirements but can elect coverage. In Arizona and Minnesota, similar rules apply.
The Bottom Line
Using independent contractors can legitimately reduce your workers comp exposure — but only if the workers are genuinely independent contractors and you have documentation to prove it. Misclassification is a serious legal and financial risk.
Talk to a RightQuote advisor about workers comp for your business, or explore business insurance options.
Part of the Workers Compensation Insurance Guide.